Family law · Legal information

How Is Custody Determined?

Author · Av. Ayşenur Konar, Avukat

Published ·

In short

Custody is determined by reading together the child's best interest and the care arrangement. The parent's sentence "I want it" is not enough on its own. The change case is in a separate writing.

The actual care, the school, and the social inquiry are the face.

A breach of personal contact is the face of enforcement.

The Ankara family court is looked at from the residence.

Related writings: a change of custody.

Custody is the basic institution that regulates, in a divorce or separation process, with which parent the child's care, education, and representation will stay. The decisive criterion in the court decision is the child's best interest. The parents' will, economic strength, or gender does not determine the result on its own. This text is for general information. The result can change in the concrete file.

Introduction

One of the subjects parents are most curious about in a divorce process is to whom custody will be given. The question "how is custody determined?" should be read not only with an emotional preference, but together with the statutory criteria, the order of the evidence, and the child's daily-life routine. The same national frame applies in the family courts in Ankara too. Local volume can affect the time. The basic principles do not change.

For the wider frame you can examine the family law page, and for the uncontested path the writing on the conditions of an uncontested divorce. Promises such as a definite result, or "it is certainly given to this parent," do not take place in this writing.

What is custody?

Custody covers the use of the rights relating to the personality and the property of a child who is not of age, and the obligation to care for, educate, and protect the child. In a divorce, custody is generally left to one of the spouses. Personal contact with the other parent is regulated separately. The practice of joint custody can come up in limited and special situations according to the statutory frame and the conditions of the concrete file. It should not be assumed automatically in every file.

The right of custody covers a wide field, such as the choice of school, health interventions, passport acts, and daily care decisions. The parent who has custody is obliged to use these powers for the child's benefit. Information of the other parent, and the right of personal contact, are also protected. The parent who does not have custody cannot give, alone, the decisions within the scope of custody over the child. During the personal-contact period, that parent attends to the child.

In practice, economic strength is not treated as decisive on its own in custody discussions. The level of income is examined in the context of meeting the child's housing and education needs. Elements such as the intensity of work, a shift system, or frequent travel can affect the capacity to care. Support of a grandmother or grandfather can be seen positively. Custody is not left directly to the grandmother. The parent's new partner relation is not, on its own, a reason for loss of custody. A concern for the child's safety can be discussed with concrete facts.

The difference between custody and guardianship

Custody rests on the status of parent. Guardianship comes up in a different legal regime, in situations of the parent's absence or lack of capacity. The subject discussed in divorce files is mostly the allocation of custody between the parents. A confusion of concepts can give birth to a risk of error in preparing a petition and a protocol.

Whom does it concern?

  • Parents in a divorce or separation process
  • Parents who are thinking of a change of custody
  • Parties who want to clarify the personal-contact calendar
  • Families for whom the child living in a different city, or abroad, is in question
  • Spouses who are preparing an uncontested protocol and writing the custody clause

Custody is not only the question "with whom will the child stay?" It affects the child's concrete life, such as school, health, the summer holiday, and the holiday arrangement. If a grandmother, a grandfather, or third persons have a care role, that can also enter the assessment. The basic discussion is between the parents.

How is custody determined? The court process

A typical custody assessment moves with these stages:

  1. The custody request being put forward in the divorce case by a petition or a protocol
  2. The parties' statements on the economic situation, the dwelling, working hours, and the capacity to care
  3. Examination of the child's age, the school situation, the health needs, and the existing actual arrangement
  4. Where needed, gathering of a social-inquiry report, witnesses, or documentary evidence
  5. Hearing of the child's view if the age and maturity are suitable
  6. The court deciding with the principle of the child's best interest
  7. Clarification of the personal-contact calendar by the decision or the protocol

The court rests not on a general allegation that one of the parties is "the better parent," but on concrete facts. Elements such as regular school attendance, health follow-up, an allegation of violence or neglect against the child, substance dependence, and a heavy tempo of work are discussed according to the file. A single negative event does not always mean loss of custody. Continuity and weight matter.

The principle of the child's best interest

This principle is at the centre of the custody decision. Headings such as the child's physical safety, emotional development, continuity of education, and the unity of siblings are assessed together. The court can prefer an arrangement that will not load the conflict between the parents onto the child. Showing the child as a party, using the child against the other side, or making the child a tool of communication can lead to a negative assessment.

The social inquiry and the evidence

A social-inquiry report offers a field observation about the home environment, the parent-child relation, and the care conditions. A school report card, a health report, a police minute, or witness accounts can also be evidence. When evidence is gathered, the child's privacy needs to be protected. Sharing the child's photograph on social media, or telling the court process to the child, can increase the emotional load.

Custody in an uncontested and a contested divorce

In an uncontested divorce the parties propose custody and personal contact together in the protocol. The court reviews the protocol. It may not accept provisions that are contrary to the child's interest or that are uncertain. In a contested divorce the parties put forward different custody requests. The evidence and witness process can be longer. In both paths the decisive criterion does not change: the child's best interest.

When the protocol is prepared, the single sentence "custody to the mother / to the father" is not enough. The personal-contact days, the sharing of holidays, the summer holiday, the place of handover, and the path of communication in case of delay should be written. If an uncertain protocol is signed so that the divorce will end, breach and change cases can arise later. For the uncontested process, the writing on the conditions of an uncontested divorce can be useful.

Personal contact and custody should be thought of together

The parent who received custody runs the daily decisions. The parent who does not have custody establishes regular contact with the child by personal contact. A well-written personal-contact calendar should cover the school days, the holidays, the summer holiday, and the special days. The place of handover and return not being clear is one of the most frequent reasons of dispute.

Obstruction of personal contact, or its continuous shortening, can prepare the ground for a request to change custody. In the same way, an allegation of conduct harmful to the child during the personal-contact period can produce a serious result. Both parents are obliged to support the child forming a healthy relation with the other parent. Personal hostility should not be reflected onto the child.

Mistakes often made

  • Showing the child as a party or using the child before the court
  • Building a strategy with a generalisation such as "mothers / fathers receive it"
  • Writing the personal-contact calendar in a way that cannot be applied
  • Making shares on social media that target the other side or the child
  • Leaving the custody subject uncertain in the protocol and saying "we will talk later"
  • Hiding or manipulating the child's school and health records
  • Making a move or a change of school without informing the other parent

Care: even if a custody decision is emotionally heavy, a practicable arrangement is needed for the child's daily stability. Obstructing personal contact in practice after the decision can give birth to a risk of a new case and of a sanction.

The basis of the custody regulation is the provisions of the Turkish Civil Code relating to family law. In divorce cases, custody is assessed in the incidental character of the divorce. The principle of the child's best interest is read together with international conventions and domestic-law practice. The duty and the procedure of trial of the family courts are subject to the relevant statutes.

In judicial practice, economic superiority is not treated as a reason for custody on its own. Meeting the child's housing, nutrition, and education needs is examined as part of the capacity to care. Elements such as the intensity of work, a new partner relation, or family support are discussed with concrete facts. Each decision is particular to the file. A general tendency does not promise a one-to-one result.

Custody files are heard intensively in the family courts in Ankara. The interval of hearings and the length of the social inquiry can affect the total time. For the variables of time, the writing how long does a divorce case last? can be looked at.

The unity of siblings and continuity of school

If there is more than one child, the court may not want the siblings to be separated. The unity of siblings often comes up from the point of view of the child's emotional safety. A change of school, the transport arrangement, and examination periods can also be taken into account in the custody decision. If there is a plan to move, the school record and the possibility of transport are assessed together. The child staying at the existing school can be seen positively from the point of view of stability. It is not decisive on its own.

A request to change custody

If the conditions change after the divorce decision becomes final, a case to change custody can be brought. Reasons such as loss of work, a move, marriage, a health problem, continuous obstruction of personal contact, or an allegation of neglect towards the child can be discussed. A change request is not accepted easily. It should be shown that the new conditions are more suitable to the child's interest. Frequent and small change requests can be refused on the ground that they break stability. The separate decision of this stage is in the writing on a case to change custody. Even after a custody decision is given, cooperation between the parents should be continued. A culture of taking decisions together for the child's education, health, and social development should be kept.

How custody is separated from the personal-contact calendar

Custody is read apart from the personal-contact calendar. The office being in Çankaya does not change the competent authority. The decision is built with the child's care arrangement and the report in the file.

Conclusion

Custody is determined, in the frame of the principle of the child's best interest, by assessing together the parents' capacity to care, the child's age, and the actual arrangement. Even if the path of an uncontested protocol or of contested proceedings differs, the criterion is the same. Writing the personal-contact calendar clearly and in a practicable way reduces the risk of a dispute after the decision.

This writing is for general information. The assessment can change according to the features of the concrete event. An examination in the frame of the current legislation is important. For the wider frame you can examine the family law page, for the uncontested process the conditions of an uncontested divorce, and for the time how long does a divorce case last?.

Frequently asked questions

Is custody given to the mother automatically?

No. In a custody decision, gender or the status of parent is not decisive on its own. The court takes the child's best interest as the basis and assesses together both parents' capacity to care, the bond formed with the child, the living conditions, and the education and health needs. In children of a young age the actual care arrangement can matter, but this does not mean an automatic result in the mother's favour. It is possible for the father to receive custody too. In the concrete file a social-inquiry report, a witness statement, or school and health records can also play a role. A general rule does not produce the same result in every event. This writing is for information. A definite result is not promised.

Does the child's age affect the custody decision?

Yes, it affects it. There is no fixed table by age. In the baby and pre-school period the need for continuous care can be more marked. At school age, elements such as the education arrangement, closeness to the school, and the unity of siblings can come forward. In adolescence the child's view can be heard. The child's preference does not decide on its own. Age is not the only criterion of the decision. The court looks for an arrangement that will protect the emotional development, the school success, and the existing routine of a child whose age is suitable. When the age changes, custody does not change automatically. A separate request and assessment are needed. Each file is examined according to its own conditions.

Are custody and personal contact the same thing?

They are not. Custody expresses the obligation of decision and of supervision on matters such as the child's care, education, health, and representation. Personal contact regulates the parent who does not have custody seeing the child on certain days and hours. Custody can stay with one parent while a wide personal contact is set up with the other parent. When the court gives custody, it also sets the contact calendar, or it approves the parties' agreement. A change of custody and a change of personal contact are different requests. One does not give birth to the other automatically. This separation should be written clearly in the protocol or in the decision. Uncertain expressions can give birth to a dispute later.

Is a social-inquiry report asked for in every file?

It is not obligatory in every file. The court can have a social inquiry made if it sees it as necessary. A request for a report is often seen especially if there is a serious allegation between the parties, a concern for the child's safety, living in different cities, or conflicting statements on the capacity to care. The report offers information about the home environment, the parent-child relation, and the child's needs. The report does not determine the result on its own. It is assessed together with the other evidence. The report process can lengthen the completion of the file. The same procedural frame applies in the family courts in Ankara too. The need for a report in the concrete file is in the court's appreciation.

How is custody determined in an uncontested divorce?

In an uncontested divorce the parties can propose together, in the protocol, the arrangement of custody and of personal contact. The court reviews the protocol from the point of view of the child's best interest. The parties' agreement may not be treated as enough on its own. Correction of arrangements that are impracticable or that look contrary to the child's interest can be asked for. It matters that the custody clause in the protocol is clear, practicable, and consistent with the contact calendar. The uncontested path can move quickly. Concessions given in a hurry on custody can give birth to regret later. For the frame of a detailed protocol, the writing on the conditions of an uncontested divorce can be read. Each event is assessed separately.

Can a custody decision be changed later?

Yes. When the conditions change, a change of custody can be requested. Reasons such as a change of work, a move, the parent's state of health, the child's education need, an allegation of misuse of the custody right, or a continuous breach of personal contact can come up. The change is not easy and not automatic. It needs to be shown that the new conditions are more suitable to the child's interest. Simple changes of life may not always be enough. A change case requires a separate procedure and evidence. Frequent change requests that would break the child's stability are also examined carefully by the court. In the concrete event the current conditions should be read together.

Can the parent who received custody go abroad?

Custody also brings responsibility on the child's place of residence and on travel. A permanent move abroad, or a long journey, is assessed separately as regards the other parent's rights and the child's interest. A one-sided move can give birth to a serious dispute and a legal sanction. Matters such as travel permission, passport acts, and continuity of school should be clarified in the protocol or in the decision. Outside emergencies, an unplanned move is risky. If there is an international dimension, additional legal regimes can come in. Each move request is examined according to the current state of the file. A general assumption of permission or of a ban is not correct.

In which court is a custody case heard in Ankara?

Custody is heard in the family court together with the divorce case, or as a separate request after the divorce. Jurisdiction is determined by the statutory rules according to the spouses' place of residence, the place where the child lives, or the nature of the case. For families living in Ankara, the competent family court is identified according to the concrete address and record particulars. A case brought in the wrong court can be delayed because of an objection to jurisdiction. While the divorce case continues, custody is also discussed in the same file. After the divorce becomes final, a change can be the subject of a separate case. The volume of the court can affect the time. The basic rules of duty do not change. A definite jurisdiction should not be interpreted without the concrete address particulars.

Related reading

This article sits under one practice area. The neighbouring guides carry the detail that does not belong in this text.

Practice areas · Family law

AK

Author

Av. Ayşenur Konar

Lawyer on the Ankara Bar Association roll, founder of Konar Hukuk. This text is general information; a specific file is reviewed separately. Author profile · Editorial policy

A consultation

We can look at the matter with you. The path depends on the documents. This is not a promise about the result.

Call